⚖️Passport Denied: The sale of EU Citizenship has come to an end
A landmark CJEU judgment has reasserted that European identity cannot be purchased, only earned through genuine ties and shared responsibility
👋Hey guys, Julien here. The French Dispatch is a reader-supported publication, and both our coverage of current affairs as well as our ability to bring you more news and information on the world around us is entirely funded by paid subscriptions and donations.
If you enjoy reading articles written by high-level experts, then make sure to support the publication by liking, subscribing, and sharing it with your friends and colleagues, and consider taking a paid subscription.
Yesterday was an important day in European history, with a legal ruling of seismic consequence being handed down this morning by the European Court of Justice.
In a decision thick with the perfume of principle and the sting of sovereignty, the ECJ declared that Malta’s much criticised golden passport scheme, formally known as the “Maltese Citizenship by Naturalisation for Exceptional Services by Direct Investment”, was in breach of European Union law.
The verdict? One cannot buy a European soul.
At the centre of this judicial opera was the peculiar alchemy through which gold from unknown sources could be transmuted into nationality. Under the Maltese scheme, foreign nationals with no real, concrete link to the island nation could, through a preordained menu of payments and investments, obtain Maltese citizenship.
And with it—automatically—European citizenship, complete with its freedoms, privileges, and passports. No cultural bond, no enduring connection. Just a signature and a wire transfer.
Fortunately the Court refused to treat citizenship as mere merchandise. While each Member State retains the sovereign right to define its own criteria for granting nationality, this sovereignty must still bow to the silent contract of the Union: one founded on solidarity, sincere cooperation, and mutual trust.
By commercialising citizenship, Malta, the judges ruled, had breached that contract, and the brutal honesty in the document was welcomed by many campaigners and citizens across Europe:
“A Member State cannot grant its nationality – and indeed European citizenship – in exchange for predetermined payments or investments, as this essentially amounts to rendering the acquisition of nationality a mere commercial transaction. Such a practice does not make it possible to establish the necessary bond of solidarity and good faith between a Member State and its citizens, or to ensure mutual trust between the Member States and thus constitutes a breach of the principle of sincere cooperation.”
The golden passport, in the eyes of the law, was fool’s gold.
The principle at stake is not merely semantic. European citizenship is not a standalone product but an inherited benefit, granted through the conferral of national citizenship and upheld through a shared architecture of rights and responsibilities.
In turning that process into a transactional procedure, the Maltese scheme became, in effect, a backdoor to Europe: one not guarded by values, but by price tags.
The Commission, which had taken Malta to Court, argued precisely this—that the scheme undermined the spirit of the Treaties and the trust between nations. The Court agreed, evoking Articles 20 TFEU and 4(3) TEU to underline its position. European citizenship, it seems, cannot be offered à la carte.
With this judgment, the message from Luxembourg is crystal clear: a Member State cannot treat nationality as a luxury good, and the practice of buying your way into our Union is now finished.
The sale of passports is, for all legal intents and European purposes, now closed.
The Court’s decision also casts a long, clarifying light on the evolving nature of European identity itself. By closing the door on transactional citizenship, the ruling reinforces a deeper vision of Union membership: one rooted not in wealth, but in belonging, in living as a part of our community, and having contributed more than just money to the European project.
It gestures towards a future where EU citizenship is not simply a legal status appended to a passport, but a civic relationship shaped by participation, solidarity, and shared values. A future where EU citizenship has to be earned through lived experiences and contributions.
In doing so, the judgment may encourage Member States to pursue more integrative approaches to citizenship, emphasising social ties, cultural integration, and democratic commitment. Far from closing Europe off, it invites a more durable, meaningful construction of the European citizenry, one built not on investments, but on mutual trust and common purpose.
As for Malta, the implications are stark. The country must comply with the Court’s judgment without delay. Should it fail to do so, the Commission may return to the bench, this time seeking financial penalties. No sunset clause, no indulgence.
Thus, the age of golden passports in the European Union has come to an end, struck down not with political rhetoric but with the clear, cold blade of the law.
One cannot purchase entry into our community of values.
At least, not anymore.
Thank you for reading the French Dispatch! If you liked what you read, you should like this post and subscribe to the newsletter by clicking/tapping the button below:
And if you’d like to contribute a coffee or two to help fuel my coverage of the wild world of politics, feel free to click on the picture below:
So, is this where Trump got the idea of the $5 Million Gold US citizenship card for rich immigrants to buy??? I’m just asking, because he surely didn’t pull that out of thin air…
I was not aware of this golden passport. It might sound easy (and cheesy) but as a convinced European, I am delighted of this decision.
Living in a country that exited the EU 5 years ago, I witness every day the gap between a country standing alone (even if I really like the UK) and a country part of something bigger based not only on economic rationale but also on strong cultural values.
My European passport is one of my most precious assets and is clearly part of my identity.
☺️🇪🇺